Challenge
40% of the Budget Going to Existing Customers
At the beginning of 2025, the DTC watch company was struggling to keep acquisition dollars focused on net-new audiences. Despite activating every exclusion tactic available in Meta Ads Manager, nearly 40% of the budget was still being spent on past customers, recent site visitors, and content engagers.
The impact was clear:
- Cost per new site visitor nearly tripled vs. the prior year
- NCROAS fell sharply
- New visitor percentage from Meta ads declined
Despite using customer list uploads, Klaviyo and Shopify syncs, capping Advantage+ budgets, excluding 180-day purchasers, and diversifying creative, growth and profitability continued to stall.
“At one point we had almost 40% of our budget being spent on recent site visitors and customers, which was not what we were trying to do at all.
”

Solution
A Trusted Referral and Fast Setup
The turning point came via a referral from Cody Plofker, CMO at Jones Road Beauty. Onboarding was straightforward — connecting Shopify and Meta accounts was all it took. Within the first week, performance began to shift. In the following weeks, with no promotions running, the performance lift remained, proving it was WasteNot driving these results.
“There are tons of tools like WasteNot out there that promise the world. But when I get a tip from a marketer I trust at a big brand, and it's shared privately rather than as a paid plug, I take it seriously.
”

Results
Efficiency Gains Across the Funnel
After months of failed attempts with Meta's native exclusions and customer list uploads, WasteNot finally gave the brand the ability to scale with confidence.
The measurable gains were dramatic and consistent: New customer efficiency improved across every metric. NCROAS rose by 59%, while acquisition costs dropped by 40%. That shift translated into growth as new customer purchases increased by 30%, and the impact carried through to the top line with overall ROAS improving by 10%.
- 59%
- Increase in nCROAS
- 40%
- Decrease in nCAC
- 10%
- Increase in total ROAS
WasteNot didn't just deliver better exclusions; it reset how the team thought about Meta altogether. It reframed Meta as the ultimate megaphone for reaching the right new people, not just retargeting existing fans.
“Every metric that the business wanted to see improved. We immediately started hitting contribution margin targets again.
”

Conclusion
Time and again, exclusions that actually work have been one of the most effective ad optimization tactics for improving spend efficiency and growth KPIs. Yet, traditional exclusion methods are woefully tedious to activate and manage, and often flat-out ineffective.
WasteNot offers a simple solution: exclusions that perform as they should, activated with ease and without the need for technical resources.
“It works. We had tried a bunch of things before that either didn't work or kind of worked. WasteNot definitively worked.
”

